Challenging Labor’s small target strategy requires building movements

May 16, 2025
Issue 
A 'Block the Budget' protest in Gadigal Country/Sydney, June 2015. Photo: Peter Boyle

The Chaser, the satirical news outlet, led its election night coverage with this: ā€œā€.Ģż

Their clairvoyancy is to be admired, because nothing the Prime Minister has said since being reelected with a bigger majority of seats disproves their point.

Albanese has been busy lowering people’s expectations with his self-serving ā€œI don’t pretend to be a revolutionary; I’m a reformistā€ quip.

Labor won the small target election strategy contest against the Coalition. Its campaign focused on already announced reforms to the public health system, Medicare, investment in childcare, free vocational training and a 20% cut to all university student debt. It had an additional for seat-by-seat bribes.

Labor avoided speaking about international issues, especially Israel’s war on Palestine. It avoided talking up the unpopular AUKUS military pact with Donald Trump and its ā€œclimate policyā€ caved into the fossil fuel corporations.

While mainstream pundits are talking up Labor’s chances of staying in power for another term after this, they discount the growing alienation from what the major parties have on offer and the swinging voter trend.

Albanese likes to position Labor as ā€œkindā€, compared to the Coalition. He said on election night that Labor ā€œtreats people with respectā€.

He’s speaking to those disaffected layers, particularly youth, who are increasingly skeptical that any party will deliver real reforms. At the end of three years, if Labor hasn’t addressed the housing and cost-of-living crises, they will vote for someone else.

Albanese’s message is that Labor will be a steady hand at managing capital for the ruling class; Labor has a ā€œkinderā€ way of shoring up the profits-first system, than Dutton’s Trumpian approach.

Labor won 94 out of 150 seats in the House of Representatives. Does it have a mandate not to lead on raising welfare payments, capping rents, taxing corporations, scrapping the undemocratic union laws and speeding up real action to stop catastrophic climate change?

Combined, Labor and the Coalition won 90% of the seats, but their vote share continues to decline — 66.5% of the nationalĀ House of Representatives (HoR) vote as at May 16 — showing growing disillusion. Far-right parties received a combined vote of 11.83% in the HoR and 13.28% in the Senate. The combined Greens and socialist vote was 12.37% in the HoR and 12.22% in the Senate.

Socialist Alliance ran a modest campaign in lower and upper house seats in four states and recorded its highest ever vote (since it formed in 2001). swing in the tightly contested seat of Wills, where the Greens’ campaign nearly ousted Peter Khalil in the context of great anger against Labor’s refusal to stand up for Palestine against Israel’s genocide. The Wills campaign, among others, point to the necessity of the left building extra-parliamentary movements for real change.

If the union and social/ecological movements don’t take up the challenge to force Labor to act, even on its mediocre program, we are likely to see a lot more window dressing.

This applies to its climate change laws and nature repair bills, its housing and future fund laws and its full funding of public schools bill. Appointing Murray Watt to the environment portfolio portends of new fix-its, but with the fossil fuel industry rather than First Nations people or the environment.

While the Greens did a good job in the last parliament of exposing Labor’s inadequate bills, that is not a strategy for change. Apart from this and blocking bills, they lacked a strategy to win more concessions from the government. It underscores the fact that just getting more MPs does not necessarily change politics or change the status quo.

Sustained mass movements that do not get waylaid on piecemeal crumbs are going to be decisive to secure progressive change.

When Coalition PM Tony Abbott delivered a horror budget in 2015, a spontaneous national ā€œBlock the Budgetā€ protests involved tens of thousands of people in capital cities and there were also sizeable protests in regional cities. It stopped parliament passing most of Abbott’s cuts.

During the Kevin Rudd-Julia Gillard Labor government, a strong climate movement mobilised against the inadequate carbon pollution reduction scheme.

The pro-Palestine campaign was the only mass movement of significance under Labor’s last term. Despite the mainstream commentary, its electoral expression dented Labor’s vote in several working-class seats. The movement’s weekly national protests for 16 months was critical to this.

But years of neoliberalism, which has led to the atomisation of the working class and a shrinking, bureaucratised union movement, holds all progressive movements back. There are no easy or quick fixes, except for those seeking real change to .

Sustained mass movement not only help expose complicit governments, they involve people in concrete activities which then enlarge their horizons about who their allies are what needs to be changed.

Socialist Alliance believes that toĀ win a truly democratic, peaceful, just and ecologically sustainable future, working people must take ownership and control of our resources out of the hands of the capitalist minority and transfer it to society as a whole. This can only be achieved through a qualitative expansion in direct democracy and democratic planning at all levels.

We are committed to doing the best we can to continue to educate, organise and mobilise working people and other oppressed groups to replace the power of the capitalists with popular power.

If you agree .

[Sue Bolton is member of the . She is also a fourth-term Merri-bek councillor in Victoria.]

You need Āé¶¹“«Ć½, and we need you!

Āé¶¹“«Ć½ is funded by contributions from readers and supporters. Help us reach our funding target.

Make a One-off Donation or choose from one of our Monthly Donation options.

Become a supporter to get the digital edition for $5 per month or the print edition for $10 per month. One-time payment options are available.

You can also call 1800 634 206 to make a donation or to become a supporter. Thank you.